Looking for PB Fit cookie recipes to try out this holiday season? Here are some great cookie recipes that are a tad healthier than most traditional cookies!
Hey there – Chantal here! I’m a mom of two and certified personal trainer.
Welcome to my site and welcome to my post about the most delicious PB fit cookies!
Have you ever tried a “healthy” cookie that promised to be as tasty as it was healthy?
If you have, then you know that it can be really hit-and-miss to try to make your favorite recipes healthy.
Not these PB Fit cookies!
But not when it comes to PB Fit cookie recipes!
If you aren’t already on the PB Fit train, it’s time to hop on. PB Fit, if explained in simple terms, is just powdered peanut butter with pea protein added.
However, since it’s been stripped of nearly all of the oil, it’s super lean (low fat compared to regular peanut butter).
It also has less calories.
Not only does the powder make for a great baking additive, it also comes in a few great varieties. You can get chocolate flavored PB Fit, Pumpkin Spice PB Fit, Vegan, and Sugar-Free.
So basically, no matter what your dietary needs are, you can use this product in some delicious PB Fit cookies.
You can even make some de-lish brownies and other baked goods.
Interested in nutrition coaching but on a budget? My online nutrition course for women is now OPEN!
But who doesn’t love a good peanut butter cookie recipe?
Related Reading: Peanut Butter Banana Protein Shake Recipe
Many people typically use their PB Fit protein shakes and smoothies, but every good fitness buff eventually ventures out into other foods. That’s why you’re here, right?
Psst! Need help with nutrition? Check out my self-paced nutrition course for weight loss!
I have only tried PB Fit in a few things, but the internet has my back on this whole PB Fit cookie recipes thing. (Seriously, I love Pinterest.)
So, when I was looking for some healthy cookie recipes (okay, at least healthy-ish) to try, I was surprised to see that so many people have already dialed the PB Fit cookie game in.
The only “bad” thing that I can find so far about these types of cookies is that they are naturally going to be all about that peanut butter flavor.
Even though chocolate flavors of peanut powder exist, they are pretty much going to be the same flavor combinations.
No chocolate cranberry or lemon cookies here!
A Few Tips for the Best Cookies
Baking cookies is already a bit of an art, but baking cookies with unconventional ingredients can be even trickier.
If you are using powdered peanut butter, a sugar substitute, or any special ingredients (i.e. specialty low-carb products), then you should keep a few things in mind.
(Even baking with natural peanut butter or almond flour can have a learning curve!)
When making these PB powder cookies, consider using your best baking sheet along with parchment paper.
Related Reading: Chocolate Mint Protein Shake
Also, since this is not regular PB we’re talking about, there is less fat content.
That being said, be sure to use cooking spray on your cookie sheet if you don’t have a cookie mat or parchment paper!
At the end of the day, the best way to figure out the best PB2 peanut butter cookies (or PB Fit, whatever) is to do a little trial and error!
15 Amazing PB Fit Cookie Recipes
Try one of these amazing PB Fit cookie recipes to satisfy your sweet tooth when the next craving hits!
Warning: PB Fit cookies may be addicting!
P.S. All of these recipes come from other wellness, fitness, and recipe bloggers. Please support them by taking a look! *Stock images used.
Related Reading: Delicious Grilled Vegetables Marinade Recipe
1. Peanut Butter Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies from Staying Close to Home
A chocolate and peanut butter lover’s dream! Try this classic combo of chocolate chip meets PB. Seriously delicious!
Who doesn’t love peanut butter chocolate chip cookies?
P.S. This might just be my favorite PB Fit cookies recipe, so go try it!
2. Classic Peanut Butter Cookies with Powdered Peanut Butter from Mini Newman
Love a classic peanut butter cookie but want to reduce fat? This is the recipe for you! Same sweet classic PB flavor, just a tad healthier!
3. PB Fit/PB2 Chocolate Peanut Butter Breakfast Cookies from Watching What I Eat
Have you ever tried breakfast cookies before? Yes, it’s a thing!
They typically have some sort of nuts or dried fruit along with oatmeal.
If you’re looking for something sweet but also a good meal prep, this recipe is it!
This recipe calls for PB2, but since it’s basically the same thing as PB Fit, I’m sure it can still work for some delish PB Fit cookies.
4. Soft Gluten Free PB Fit Cookies from Simply Low Cal
PB Fit cookies that are GF? YES!
If you have Celiac disease or simply want to reduce your gluten intake, this one is for you!
Enjoy some delicious peanut butter cookies – but without the gluten and with less fat.
A great compromise that can still satisfy your sweet tooth! These PB2 cookies are definitely worth a try.
Related Reading: 17 Gluten-Free Pumpkin Desserts To Try This Fall
5. 3 Ingredient PBFit Cookies from I’mHeatherR
If you’re looking to keep it simple, this is the recipe for you. It has just a few ingredients, and it’s also customizable.
So, if you have a hankering for some sweets but don’t have all of the ingredients, check the substitution list and go for it!
6. Peanut Butter & Banana from Just A Pinch
If you’re looking for a cookie recipe that uses sugar alternatives (such as Stevia), this is a good option.
(It has a brown sugar alternative and calls for a bit of maple syrup.)
You still get that yummy peanut butter and chocolate flavor, but without regular sugar. This recipe uses Hershey’s Kisses on the top of each cookie, but that is optional too.
(Or use chocolate chips!)
Related Reading: Beginner Whole Wheat Sourdough Bread Recipe
7. Blondies from Dr. Sara Solomon
Okay, so these aren’t cookies but they are pretty dang close. I love blondies, and this recipe calls for black beans (this is becoming pretty popular, so give it a try)!
This recipe not only calls for powdered peanut butter, it also calls for added whey protein powder.
If you’re into post-workout treats, look no further than these PB Fit cookies.
There you have it friends! 15 delicious PB Fit cookie recipes to try next time the baking itch hits.
Better yet, plan ahead and make these before your cravings for sweets come along.
You can even make some PB Fit cookies ahead and have cookie dough in your freezer for whenever you want.
You’ll feel better knowing these cookies have less fat, calories, and potentially more protein! Win-win.
Related Reading: Beginner List Of Good Fats To Eat
I hope this helps you if you are on the keto diet / high protein or simply if you want to eat a little bit healthier.
May you find a great alternative to your favorite classic cookie!
If you have any other PB Fit cookie recipes to suggest, I’d love to know.
Please leave me a comment on your fave PB Fit cookies below!
Looking for more? Here are some other articles that you might like: